Your Court, Your Community, Basketball Kaki!

Indiana basketball vs Winthrop overreactions: Are Hoosiers gradually improving or treading water?


BLOOMINGTON — Nothing came easy for Indiana basketball in a 77-68 win over Winthrop on Sunday afternoon.

The Hoosiers (10-3; 1-1 Big Ten) closed out the game with an 8-0 run that was their longest of the game. They never led by double-digits and had to overcome a 1 for 20 performance from 3-point range.

Here’s our overreactions to IU’s latest victory:

More: Indiana basketball coach Mike Woodson: “Not going to address” Oumar Ballo’s absence against Winthrop

Indiana's Myles Rice (1) scores during the Indiana versus Winthrop men's basketball game at Simon Skjodt Assembly Hall on Sunday, Dec. 29, 2024.Indiana's Myles Rice (1) scores during the Indiana versus Winthrop men's basketball game at Simon Skjodt Assembly Hall on Sunday, Dec. 29, 2024.

Indiana’s Myles Rice (1) scores during the Indiana versus Winthrop men’s basketball game at Simon Skjodt Assembly Hall on Sunday, Dec. 29, 2024.

Is Indiana basketball making gradual improvements or stuck in neutral?

Indiana point guard Myles Rice, who led all scorers with 18 points, tried to put a positive spin on the win over Winthrop.

“I think gradually we’ve been getting better and better,” Rice said. “We have a lot of close games. Teams are trying to come in here and win, as well. And I mean we just, like I said, game-by-game, I feel like we’re improving.”

The problem with Rice’s rosy outlook on the future is that IU is no closer to answering the question marks it had coming into the season than it was two months ago.

What is the Hoosiers’ offensive identity? Can Malik Reneau and Oumar Ballo co-exist? Who is going to make shots? Those remain pressing concerns as IU jumps back into Big Ten play this week.

Woodson sounded upbeat as well about some of the strides IU made defensively by holding the Eagles to just 20 free-throw attempts — they came into the game averaging 32.1 attempts per game — and well under their season scoring average (86.2 points).

Those accomplishments are a little bit like fool’s gold when you consider how Winthrop’s success against non-Division 1 opponents — they beat Piedmont, Averett and Bob Jones University by an averaged of 50.3 points — inflated its season stats.

This was an Eagles team that lost by double-digits to Louisville and Florida State and barely cracked the 50-point mark in a loss against a sub-.500 Virginia Tech team.

It’s just hard to make the case that Indiana is ready to make a run in the Big Ten after struggling to close out Chattanooga (No. 175 Ken Pom ranking) and Winthrop (No. 177) in back-to-back games.

It’s now or never for Indiana’s leading scorer Malik Reneau

Mike Woodson gave Langdon Hatton a game ball after Sunday’s win, but it should have really come from Malik Reneau. Hatton’s inspired play — he had seven points, a team-high 11 rebounds and three blocks — helped IU overcome Reneau playing just 14 minutes.

Reneau spent the afternoon battling his old nemesis foul trouble, and the latest bout came in a game where he knew IU was short-handed in the front court with Ballo sitting out.

After getting an extended breather in the first half, he picked up a second foul within 90 seconds of checking back in and sat out the final 8:13 of the half. He went right back to the bench early in the second half after picking up his third foul with 18:22 left in the game.

Woodson said he was having “flashbacks” to Reneau’s freshman year when he averaged 6.8 fouls per 40 minutes, but IU’s leading scorer has never really turned the page on the issue.

He led the Big Ten with 103 personal fouls last year and came into Sunday’s game ranked fourth in the conference in fouls per game (2.8). This was his second straight game with four fouls and sixth time he’s reached the mark this season.

It’s just far too common of an occurrence at this point in Reneau’s career — he made his 49th career start on Sunday — especially since he doesn’t have to abandon what makes him successful to avoid picking up fouls.

This is simply about Reneau having better situational awareness for a team that now more than ever depends on his offensive production.

More: IU basketball vs. Winthrop player ratings: Hoosiers struggle, but bench player saves day

Nothing funny about Indiana basketball’s 3-point struggles

Luke Goode’s 3-pointer with 17:04 left in the first half had the unique distinction of being both the first and last made 3-pointer of the game for the Hoosiers.

Indiana’s 3-point shooting woes are nothing new — the team shot 32.4% last season while attempting just 15.5 attempts per game (ranked No. 344 out of 351 D1 teams) — but the program is reaching new levels of futility.

This was the fourth straight game the team shot under 30% (tied for the longest stretch of Woodson’s tenure) and third straight game it missed at least 15 3-point attempts (the longest such stretch of Woodson’s tenure). The Hoosiers missed 27 3-point attempts in a loss at Nebraska earlier this month.

“You know, shooting, it’s a funny thing, man,” Woodson said. “They were all good looks. So I can’t sit here and complain that they were bad shots. They have just got to keep working, and eventually they will fall.”

But will they?

Indiana made an attempt at bolstering their 3-point shooting by adding Goode, who has struggled and only hit multiple 3-pointers in three games. Mackenzie Mgbako is the team’s next best outside shooter and he’s been streaky.

Woodson is right to say they are probably both due for better shooting performances, but enough of the season has gone by to safely say that IU won’t be able to rely on the 3-point shot for a consistent source of offense.

Michael Niziolek is the Indiana beat reporter for The Bloomington Herald-Times. You can follow him on X @michaelniziolek and read all his coverage by clicking here.

This article originally appeared on The Herald-Times: Overreactions after Indiana basketball struggles closing out Winthrop





Source